Chapter 8. Entities and Stuff in Economics

Summary: Economics puts too much emphasis on entities instead of the Good that we are called to do, resulting in fragmentation, envy and greed. Dooyeweerd helps us avoid this by making meaningfulness the foundation.

Status of chapter: - Being revamped in its content

Types of thing meaningful in economics: money, trees, timber, chairs, wooden pallets, banks, businesses, households, firms, farms, corporations, governments, markets, economies, budgets, debts, sectors, commodities, goods, services, products, customers, suppliers, cryptocurrencies, taxes, purchases, and of course human individuals.

How may we understand them? What we have discussed in previous chapters, on meaningfulness, values, functioning and Good and Harm are not enough to understand things in all their vast array of different kinds of thing: stuff, tangible things, things with agency, abstract things, abstract things, measurements, roles, and so on. How may we usefully understand the nature of their various types (how does a government differ from a household?), their coming-into-being and their demise, and what makes for good and non-so-good things of each type (bad money, good bank)? And why?

That is what we discuss in this Chapter. We will discuss three types of thing in more detail: money, firms and economies as exemplars of others, but first we review a dozen or more problems related to economics that conventional ways of understanding things engender, and how Dooyeweerd's way of understanding things helps address them. As you read this chapter, please keep referring back to the section in Chapter 3 that explains Dooyeweerd's understanding of things and types of thing, including terms like "structure of individuality" and "enkaptic relationships". Remember our principle, with which we ended Chapter 4 and even Chapter 3: all should aim to contribute to Multi-aspectual Overall Good.

8-1. Being-oriented and Meaning-oriented Thinking

Summary: Being-orientation, which is rife in most fields including economics, generates many problems, philosophical and practical, because it presupposes existence-as-such. Meaning-orientation, which understands existence as a multi-aspectual structures of individuality, provides a basis for overcoming the problems.

===== intro: ensure we make clear what we do in ent-o thinking : intro of 8-1.

This section needs critique. It has not been discussed anywhere else as far as we know.

What we call Being-oriented thinking is when our thinking focuses too much on things and their types, at the expense of meaningfulness and normativity, presupposing these as secondary and optional, a kind of property added to things and secondary to them. This is known as the Is-Ought or Fact-Value divide and, since Value is foundational to economics, it does not serve economics well. Being-orientation arose in ancient Greece and has lain at the root of European and Western philosophy ever since. It is part of what Dooyeweerd called the Immanence-Standpoint that has, he argued, misled philosophy since the ancient Greeks.

By contrast, Dooyeweerd adopted what we will call a Meaning-orientation (his term, transcendence-standpoint) such that Being is something that arises from Meaningfulness and is best understood in relation to its varied aspects. Each aspect is a mode of being. There is no Being-as-such but only Being-as-X, where X is an aspect. A pen is a pen by virtue of its meaningfulness in the lingual aspect, a tree is a tree by virtue of the biotic aspect; see Chapter 3.

In the section on Philosophical context of a Meaning-oriented understanding of things in Chapter 3, especially the diagram, it is clear that to most philosophy the thing (without reference to aspects), the being, is just a generalised, amorphous blob, which Kant presupposed to exist as a Ding an Sich: thing in itself and found he could never engage with. As we discuss in what follows, this Being-oriented presupposition breeds confusion and a dozen other problems. By contrast, to Dooyeweerd, each being is already meaningful in a way that differs from other types of thing. This helps avoid many confusions, and especially to understand tangible things like trees and planks, stuff like money, agents like businesses and abstract things like economies.

We discuss two types of problem that arise from Being-orientation, philosophical and practical, the former about how Being-orientation affects theory-making and the latter, human behaviour. Either section may be read first.

8-1.1 Philosophical Problems of Being-oriented Thinking

Summary: Being-oriented thinking leads to a number of philosophical problems, that are relevant to economics, which can be overcome by meaning-oriented thinking.

1. In general, Being-orientation obscures the real nature of things and types of thing, because all it lets us see is that amorphous blob, the thing. Meaning-orientation directs us, first and foundationally, to the diversity of types of thing, each type defined by a structure of individuality, a profile of aspects that is unique for each type and which governs the coming-into-being of things of that type, their occurring, their meaningfulness, their goodness or badness, and their demise. See the section on Structures of individuality in Chapter 3. Each type that is called "money" has a different structure of individuality, as discussed later. This obscuring manifests itself in several ways.

2. Being-orientation leads us into the fallacy of composition, in which we treat one type of thing as too similar to another, attributing properties of one to another, assuming that both function in the same way and that what is good for one is good for the other.

Examples:

Meaning-orientation reveals differences between types of thing right from the start, by making clear which aspects are essential to the destination, the coming-into-being, the goodness and the demise of the thing, and the ways they are: the structure of individuality. For example, whereas households and government debt are both meaningful in the economic, juridical (of what is due) and quantitative aspects, households are also meaningful in the spatial (where they live) while government debt is meaningful in the aesthetic aspect (harmony of the national currency) and juridical. With its juridical leading, which is post-economic, governments make laws or decisions about the currency used within its jurisdiction, which the household has no power over and must accept. Debt, therefore, is governed by different laws and norms in governments than in households. Asking what makes each kind of entity meaningful and in what ways helps us overcome this fallacy.

3. Related to this, being-orientation exacerbates paradoxes, because it clouds our view so it is more likely that we shall stumble into them. Example: The Paradox of Thrift is that when households spend less and save, then overall saving reduces and/or the economy fails to grow. A meaning-orientation, to multi-aspectual functioning will tend to clarify and resolve them. See the section on paradoxes in Chapter 6.

4. Almost the reverse of the fallacy of composition, Being-orientation can lead us to overplay differences in type. This is especially so in the abstract idea of levels in economics. In particular, microeconomics and macroeconomics are taught as two completely separate topics, so that we cannot understand the links between them. It also diverts us from the possibility of other levels, such as meso and global. Levels are discussed later, where it is shown how meaning-oriented thinking with Dooyeweerd's aspects. Whereas there are aspects in which their functioning differs there are also aspects in common and all levels, and the relationships between them, may be understood via this and inter-aspect dependency.

5. Being-orientation tends to misunderstand relationships, reducing most to part-whole rather than recognise other types, such as between a city and its orchestra or football team. This leads to category errors. Example: Several attempts to discuss the fallacy of composition treat the household as part of the nation, including that on Wikipedia at the time of writing this. (Systems thinking often over-emphasises the part-whole relationship when treating each system as a subsystem of a wider system.) Meaning-orientation freed Dooyeweerd to expand the understanding of relationships between wholes, that of enkapsis, as explained in Chapter 3, which can be helpful to understand:

The full application of Dooyeweerd's idea of enkapsis requires research and discussion.

6. Being-orientation conceals normativity, the difference between good and bad. This is especially so nowadays, since the pervasion of Western culture with the Is-Ought or Fact-Value divide, by which our thinking about things which has no concern about whether they are good or bad but only what they are and what they do (which of course is the major theme of Chapter 7). To consider normativity it must bolt it on, or else go to the opposite extreme of legalism. Meaning-orientation brings normativity right into the centre, because meaningfulness implies goodness or corresponding badness.

7. Being-orientation traps us in fruitless debates about whether X is a 'real' Y, for example, are cryptocurrencies real money? Such debates have no basis for being resolved, except when on view is powerful enough to suppress rather than answer its alternative. A meaning-orientation focuses on whether money and crytocurrencies are meaningful, and function, in in the same way in the aspects that are most important in money. See later about Money, where we find that money itself is many different things.

8. Being-orientation can tend towards too static a conception of things. A similar static notion infects various models of homo economicus and assumptions about organisations. The abstract thing that is culture is often presupposed as fixed and unchanging, robbing us of hope, especially by some recent thinkers who wanted above all to emphasise its importance in economics, whereas in reality culture gradually develops and we might hope for change (as in Trainer [===] and as discussed in the discussion of Culture). In theory, Whitehead's process philosophy might overcome this by its foundational dogma that all is process but, in the end, what it tends to do is fix the type of process it takes to be foundational and not allow it to be questioned or consider other types of process. And it exhibits most of the other problems too, such as ignoring normativity. Instead, with his meaning-oriented perspective, Dooyeweerd tackles the dynamic nature of things head-on, starting Volume III of his magnum opus with the challenge that the linden tree in his garden and the book in which he scrawls annotations and which loses its cover remain as themselves despite change, yet the antique shawl when hung on a wall as a decoration becomes something different. It is his idea of structures of individuality that enable him to account for this, in that the main aspects in which the tree and book are meaningful do not change (biotic, lingual) though their functioning in them is dynamic, while that of shawl changes, from the sensory aspect (to keep people warm) to the aesthetic aspect (a decoration). As we discuss in Chapter 6 and a longer discussion of Culture, it is useful to understand culture as society's functioning in the ethical and pistic aspects - but the shape of this (a culture at one point in time) itself changes because of society's functioning the pistic aspect, i.e. what it believes to be of ultimate meaningfulness, changes. This is especially seen in religious revivals such as the Reformation and the Wesleyian revival.

9. Being-orientation makes it too easy to attribute agency to that which does not possess agency, such as "Money talks!" We need a sound way understand such a statement. Meaning-orientation opens such statements up to systematic scrutiny. "Money talks" is a lingual analogy, and, as suggested in Chapter 3, what actually usually occurs is that people worship money and thus, if offered money, will tend to do what the giver wants, and the connotation of the phrase is that this happens even though they know it is wrong (which is another pistic functioning).

10. In short, Being-orientation and Meaning-orientation direct us to different paradigms, ways of thinking and other presuppositions that direct the models, theories and general rules we formulate. So, changing to a Meaning-orientation will deeply affect the extant body of economic theory. But that need not disrupt economic theory because most current theory is seen, by this foundation, not so much as wrong and to be replaced, as in need to critique and enrichment, just as the theories of Newtonian mechanics are now seen as special-case approximations of Einteinian mechanics. Thus, later, we offer pointers to enrich current theories of money in a way that is largely continuous with current thinking but broadens and deepens it in ways that actually work better in practice. This becomes clear as we consider some of the practical problems of Being-oriented thinking.

8-1.2 Practical Problems of Being-orientation Thinking

Summary: Being-orientation leads us to treat things in ways that do not work well, especially in analysis and planning.

Only indirectly, if at all, do those philosophical limitations affect everyday life. Being-orientation affects everyday life directly in at least the following ways.

1. Being-orientation narrows down how we treat things, in a form of reductionism (Chapter 4). Example: The business as nothing but a money-maker for its owners (or its workers). Example: Human beings as nothing but self-interested rational economic actor, Chapter 6. Meaning-orientation sees each type of thing as defined or governed by aspectual structures of individuality, which stimulates curiosity and discussion about the role of each aspect in the being of the thing and its internal relationships. Even a simple version can help us understand things more clearly, for example:

Money:

Firm / Business:

Government:

The Economy:

Exchange:

Of course, each functions in many more aspects; money cannot be money without implicit agreement about its value (socia) and trust in it (ethical); we will discussion money later. Bringing in all aspects necessary to each type of thing, i.e. filling out their structures of individuality, reveals in what ways they are different. Table t8-levels suggests the structures of individuality for economic organisations at different levels.

Table t8-levels. Structures of individuality of several levels of organisation in economics

Structures of individuality of several levels of organisation in economics. ===,===

Note that each of these actually functions in all aspects but those given in the table are the main ones that are normally essential for a thing to be of that type of thing.

Humans are fully multi-aspectual, as mentioned in Chapter 3, but roles that humans take (e.g. as stakeholders in a firm, project, etc.) are each meaningful in different aspects and hence have different structures of individuality.

===== ghere 18 September 2025 This lends types of thing their richness and flexibility. Dooyeweerd's idea of structures of individuality allow a measure of freedom and variability among instances of a type. An aspectual understanding of the nature of things also inherently and implicitly directs our attention to good and bad about things and that all things have a meaningful mandate to which their development aims.

Such differences imply that we cannot treat debt or money as the same at each level. Much economics writing or discourse (including Doughnut Economics) suffers from lacking a good understanding of the human being and other entities.

2. Being-orientation tends to distort law, to dictate narrow conditions for the demise of things. Example: Under several legal systems, financial insolvency is by far the main condition for a business or organisation ceasing to exist - rather than, for instance, whether it does net Good or Harm. A meaning-oriented approach would instead include the entity's functioning (Good or Bad, discussed in Chapter 7) in multiple aspects; which aspects are included in such judgments should depend on historical situation.

3. Being-orientation seems also to encourage many of us to assign humans to two classes, Goodies and Baddies, resulting in the insights about one group being ignored by those who support the other group. Meaning-orientation directs us to explore==== the variety of ways a person is good and bad. This has practical implications, discussed below.

4. Being-orientation leads us to treat things as sacrosanct, such that their survival and 'growth' is treated as more important than the good or harm they do, to be protected at all costs. Much Good, whether social, environmental or sometimes even legal, is often sacrificed for them. This can be seen at several levels.

The survival of a firm is often used to excuse the environmental damage or social harm it does. Then, once it is 'safe' its growth and rivalry against its peers becomes of absolute importance (sacrosanct) and much is sacrificed to achieve this. Example: Microsoft committed itself to become carbon-negative by 2030, but then entered the AI race and its carbon emissions jumped 30%, and now it is considering going back on its commitment to renewable energy [Note: AI and Datacentres].

Sectors of the economy are protected by governments and encouraged to grow even when they cause considerable harm. Example: The road transport sector, which generates massive climate change emissions and being responsible for many deaths, much ill health and wildlife destruction, despite half the road-miles being unnecessary [Note: Road Transport]. The overt reasons given by governments for protecting such sectors are usually that they are a source of revenue, jobs and also seen as necessary for the reputation of the government.

This tendency to treat firms as sacrosanct is one of the drivers towards monopolies, and their harmful impact on innovation etc.; see RLDG discussion on monopolies. [Note: Business Survival]. It is also a driver of much Harmful economic activity, in that much is excused on the pretext of keeping a firm surviving - and then, once its survival is secure, of it growing and beating its rivals. In all this, the firm is sacrosanct - a gross dysfunction in the pistic aspect. It might even become an idol, something that people sacrifice not only for but to.

Meaning-orientation frees us to ask "Why is it so bad about a firm not growing faster than its rivals? Even, why exactly is it that the firm should survive at all costs?" Referring to aspects can help us systematically separate out answrs to such questions so they may be discussed. Example: A firm might be the core of a community (social aspect), have a company culture and set of values that is worth preserving (ethical, pistic) whereas another company might not. So, the decision as to whether a firm should survive or not should no longer be driven==== by juridical-economic (i.e. pre-ethical) factors like insolvency, but by considering every aspect. An aspectual view both opens up the possibility that a prized sector but harmful can by shrunk or that a business can cease, and offers guidance on how these can be achieved without undue pain. It also helps us understand reasons why such might be necessary for contributing to Multi-aspectual Overall Good at this time in history, in that it provides a basis for properly considering Harm and Uselessness (Chapter 7).

5. Being-orientation restricts our ability to judge the quality (goodness, badness) of things, mainly because of the divorce of is from ought in most philosophy influenced by Kant. Such judgments are important in decision-making at all levels, and also in courts of law, where clear definitions are often needed but Being-orientation generates interminable strife over tiny points rather than promoting true justice. Example: Is it valid to treat hospitals primarily as money-making ventures, or houses as merely investments rather than homes? Are students to be treated primarily as units of funding ("customers"), and only secondarily as human beings who learn. These feel inappropriate but Being-orientation finds it difficult to explain why. It also gives little guidance as to in what special circumstances such treatment (considering only the quantitative-economic aspect) might be valid, such as in preparing annual accounts. Via aspects, meaning-orientation provides a basis for judging the quality (value, goodness, badness) of things, in a way that goes beyond functionalism and subjectivism - as discussed in Chapter 5. We may distinguish two kinds of quality of a thing.

One relates to its being a good instance of its type. Example: Why is it that a hospital bent on money-making is, intuitively, a bad hospital? It is because the main aspect(s), which defines the mandate of the hospital (biotic, ethical), are being forcibly replaced by and subjected to the economic aspect. Hospitals do, of course, function in the economic aspect, that is only in service to its two main aspects.

The other is to do with its functioning in all aspects, and how well it contributes to Multi-aspectual Overall Good. A good bank, for instance, is not just one that stores one's money or lends money and one can rely on (economic, pistic aspects) but one where the branch managers are part of the community, have a friendly attitude and explain things well to customers (social, ethical, lingual aspects). This allows aspects to be brought into the picture that are not essential to it fulfilling its type, but to go further, yet within the same framework of thinking rather than as a bolt-on.

6. Under Being-orientation, cohorts of people become too rigidly understood, and often opposed to each other competitively. The most basic form of this is when people are seen as Goodies and Baddies. Rigidity can also happen when we consider stakeholders (in a company or a venture), with harmful consequences, usually because in most cases there are many more types of stakeholder than are usually considered. One type of harm comes from ignoring stakeholders that do not have loud voices. This includes 'ordinary' people on one hand and the environment, fauna and flora on the other.

Example, in a mining operation, the mine owners, the mine workers, the customers, the machine manufacturers, the local authority are the more audible stakeholders, while the local people or community, the local environment, and its flora and fauna, are have traditionally been overlooked - though things might be improving now.

Another type of harm arises when one type of stakeholder is deliberately prioritised, for example by a country's legal system.

Example: When a company fails, various stakeholders are affected - including employees, customers, shareholders, and those who suffer or gain from the operation of the company, such as local residents and ecology or the suppliers of raw materials. In English Law, shareholders are prioritized over the others, leading to costly disputes and unfair treatment of other stakeholders.

Such things narrow down Multi-aspectual Overall Good and they rob economic activity of the trust and collaborative spirit that is essential for its good operation, and force us back onto unproductive attempts at self-protection. So it is no surprise that stakeholder economics is increasingly replacing mere shareholder economics (who are only one type of stakeholder). With meaning-orientation, stakeholders may be understood as roles defined by aspectual functioning, as discussed in the next section, and, if we keep to the principle that every aspect is equally important then we might avoid such traps.

What happens on the demise of the entity is determined by the pistic functioning (beliefs) of society that generates the legislation to deal with that event, for example ownership is deemed most important in English Law but it could be responsibility of the entity instead, to ecological environment, to the workers who built it up, to customers who have paid but not been supplied, and the community around.

7. Being-orientation leads to an unhelpful and harmful understanding of property as "mine", "ours", not accessible to others. This can exacerbate greed and envy by owners and would-be owners when coupled with selfish attitudes, which in turn can exacerbate poverty and other forms of injustice [Note: Politics of Greed, of Envy]. This is especially so when we treat money as an owned commodity rather than as flow of value through all; see below. As a result, many firms and criminal enterprises are always on the lookout for ways to shift money from our pockets to theirs (whether stealing or with our consent). (x Christians will remember Jesus treated property as of secondary importance [Note: Jesus on property]. x) With a meaning-orientation, property, as entity, is understood via its aspectual structure of individuality, involving several main aspects. In this foundation for rethink, property is understood as a respected resource that enables functioning (economic aspect), a possibility, which is my/our responsibility (juridical aspect), held in trust, to contribute to Multi-aspectual Overall Good (ethical aspect). This resonates with understanding money as flow.

8. Related to this, Being-orientation focuses on rights rather than responsibilities. Rights adhere to entities while responsibilities are a statement of all others and the meaningfulness of an entity is found most immediately not in itself but in its being-among-others. Responsibilities (or "duties") are more fundamental than rights [Moyn 2016], which presuppose responsibilities. Simpson [1997, 29] outlines four problems of dwelling on rights, all of which affect economics: responding "simply as justice demands" so that "passions of rectitude" like resentment or respect overrule concern, compassion and love (making economics harsh); "when claims of rights collide with personal attachments or calculations of benefit, the right systematically prevails"; responsibilities and benevolence to others are ignored; and "the perception of rights also promotes one's fundamental separateness from others" (exacerbating the wrong kind of self-interest, competitiveness and blame-fixing, such as of the Jews in Europe before WW2). Being-orientation provides no basis for judging whether for example "respect or compassion, rights or goods, duty or virtue, self or other should prevail in oral deliberation. ... theories of justice, utility, and community cannot successfully establish any such priority" (which is no help if we want to reduce the isolation of economics from other spheres of life). This, Simpson notes, is a philosophical problem; it is interesting that few economics thinkers, whether conventional or recent, seriously discuss responsibility. A meaning-orientation automatically steers us to responsibility in that we become very aware of normative thrust towards Good (value) of multiple kinds (Chapter 5) and of the repercussions of what we do that are meaningful in various aspects (Chapter 6) and thereupon towards "responsibilities and benevolence to others" [Simpson 1997] (ethical aspect). It is the post-juridical aspects that provide a basis for establishing priorities among rights; an Being-orientation has no sound basis for doing this. That responsibilities are meaningful in post-juridical aspects makes them more fundamental than rights [Moyn 2016]. ===== should that be in Chapter 6, functioning, instead?

We can see indications even in conventional economics of a move away from Being-oriented thinking. For instance, Mazzucato [Mission, 205] argues that markets should be treated as outcomes and economic should be driven by purpose. ===== need other examples.

[this to chp6 or to page on GDP?=====] For instance, it is significant that Kuznets chose the functioning of monetary transactions as the foundation for assessing the health of a nation's economy, GDP, rather than capital or assets. That GDP has 'worked' for so long might be evidence that that that this way of understanding takes us closer to the real operation of the economic aspect than does Being-orientation. Of course, GDP has many flaws, but they become clearly understood when we think in terms of aspectual functioning and values: (a) it conflates Harm with Good, (b) it ignores value for which no money is paid, (c) it distorts all value by reducing it all to money; these are discussed in Chapter 7 and in more detail in the page on GDP.

===== ghere 6 September 2025

8-1.3 Towards Meaning-Oriented Thinking About Things

So how do we think about things with meaning-orientation, especially with the many types of type of think we encounter in economics - agents, objects, stuff, abstractions, and so on? Types of things are defined by profiles of aspects that play a necessary role in being of that type of thing.

A meaning-oriented perspective automatically and naturally combines being with functioning (process) and normativity (good and bad) and also rationality and possibility. Each aspect 'defines' a distinct kind of every one of those. So we can very easily slip between them and thinking about each can readily and validly inform the others.

===== fig: horiz and vertical table of these and aspects. 2 'slices' through reality with meaning-orientation. What we are aiming at is to identify the role each aspect plays in the real experience of that type of thing (including exceptional cases) and decide which are essential to being that type of thing and which are less essential, and why.

Example: Below, we discuss what money is, and will use this as an example of thinking this out money as a means of exchange (but not for instance as a commodity to bet on). We might go through the following steps, sometimes trying to decide which aspects to include in the structure of individuality and sometimes trying to think of how money functions in practice, and sometimes when it is good and bad money. (The steps need not be in the order shown, some steps might not be relevant, and there might be other steps not included above.)

Money actually functions in all aspects in human life, but those mentioned above are part of a discussion on which aspects are essential for a thing to be money (for exchange). Which of those above are essential and which are less so? To some extent, our decision will depend on context and culture, especially our own pistic and ethical functioning as we think about it. For example, the kinematic aspect of flow would be essential if we consider strictly money as a means of exchange or payment. But some might wish to relax that and include money as a store of wealth or, more precisely, tokens of potential value. Then the kinematic aspect would not be essential. The decision to relax or not is a commitment (pistic functioning) and is often linked to personal commitment to an idea - especially by academics! We will refer to the above list when we discuss money below.

Other aspects in which money functions - for example the psychical aspect of its colour (if cash) or the emotional feeling that money evokes in us, or the pistic aspect of what we believe about money, such as make it an idol, are not essential parts of its structure of individuality.

In all this, it is useful to avoid committing too stubbornly to types of thing. This is because things might be of several types and they might even change their type. When a thing is of different types, it will have several different structures of individuality. When a thing changes its type, its structure of individuality will change. If we commit stubbornly then fruitless debates ensue, wasting much time and even destroying friendships.

Stakeholders may be differentiated by aspect. For example, in the mining operation mentioned earlier, for the owners the economic and pistic aspects are important, for the workers, the economic, juridical and physical (rocks) are important, for local authorities, the juridical and social aspects are important, for the local community, the social and psychical (noise), and for the environment, fauna and flora, the biotic and physical. Some stakeholders are affecteds, having no agency in the venture but suffer or enjoy repercussions, while others are affectees, who have power and therefore responsibility. It is tempting to see these are objects and subjects, but in fact all are involved in subject-subject relationships in their important aspects. A full aspectual theory of stakeholders has yet to be formulated; research is needed.

In most cases in economics, we will be considering wholes rather than parts, but we will also come across enkaptic structural wholes, in which several wholes are bound together. The economy is like this: a correlative enkapsis of all the individual transactions that go on, and perhaps some other things, depending on what kind of definition we want - for example, whether to include unpaid economic activity in the economy, as SNA25 is attempting to do. Dooyeweerd also recognises a class of things which he calls "semi-manufactured products" such as planks of wood or nails, the destination of which is to enable creation of other products.

Notice that our understanding of things exceeds formal definitions and especially legal definitions (such as of a company as legal entity), but it will always be able to embrace and include those. It quite naturally embeds normativity into our thinking, whether things are good or bad, thus annihilating the Is-Ought, Fact-Value dichotomy. It also can indicate in what ways we should respect each type of thing, and maybe its 'rights' in law. All this enable us to arrive at a fuller, more appropriate understanding of things, which promises to fit the real world better.

Now we use this thinking to understand money, firms, markets and the economy, as exemplars of types of stuff, agents and processes. ===== ghere 22 September 2025

8-2. Money

The following is a summary derived from our full discussion of Money.

  • Money is not value; it is a token of value.
  • Money is not commodity; it is a flow.
  • Money is not owned; it is an enabler of Good functioning for which we temporarily bear responsibility.

  • The Problem of Money:

    Money is important, yet generates many problems. Many problems of money are widely recognised and several others are less recognised. Together, they include:

    Sources: [scribd], [Ajibola 2019].

    Problems with Extant Discussion of Money

    Our Approach

    Money (but see below):

    ===== have different moneys: money as purchase (econ vaue, kin movement thereof, lingual token, social acceptance), money as currency (jur state too, eth trust), money as store of wealth (...), etc.

    Currency:

    Taxes:

    (Spare template:)

    8-6 Firms, Companies, Businesses

    Business:

    Firm:

    Bank:

    8-5 Markets

    What is a market? A simple view is that a market is "a set of conditions which allow buyers and sellers of a commodity to get in touch with each other ..." [Thomas 1939, 60]. Thomas then adds an interesting extra condition, which shows that to define a market is not quite as simple as that: "... which pernit competition between buyers on the one hand and seller on the other." Competition does occur in markets but is it truly essential?

    More recently, [Polanyi 1977] has discussed what markets and market economies are. "The production and distribution of material goods is carried on through a self-regulated system of markets, governed by laws of its own, the so-called laws of supply and demand motivated in the last resort by two simple incentives, fear of hunger and hope of gain [p.87]. We need to ask several questions. What is the regulation of the system that makes it a market? What is meant by "self-regulation"? What are the laws that govern it; are they really only the laws of supply and demand? Polanyi suggests they include motivation by fear of hunger and hope of gain, but is that all? What is meant by material goods or commodities? And, why does Polanyi not include competition as Thomas did?

    We can answer those questions aspectually and with other portions of Dooyeweerd's philosophy because each is a question about meaningfulness. Regulation refers to there being a law-side, a set of laws that enables markets to operate as markets. It is an analogy from the juridical aspect applied across all aspects (each aspect gives laws). Self-regulation can refer to the fact that there is one aspect whose laws are primary in enabling markets to work, which we might presume is the economic, but will discuss below. That is, markets can operate without being enabled by the laws of other aspects (except for those on which the primary aspect depends foundationally). Adam Smith may be seen as presupposing this and trying to work out what the economic aspect is, in that many before him had see economics as operating by the beneficence of the wealthy towards the poor and he knew that the poor can be provisioned in ways other than that: economics operates by laws of an economic aspect without the need for the ethical aspect of beneficence. We have seen in Chapter 4 that the economic aspect concerns much more than just supply and demand, though of course these have special meaning in markets. Polanyi is correct to draw our attention to fear of hunger and hope of gain as motivations but one gets the impression that he is over-influenced evolutionary theory to reduce everything to the biotic or psychical and not does not allow himself to fully grasp the functioning of the ethical and pistic aspects, which are discussed in Chapter 6. Competition is also a motivation, not just an 'economic fact' in that even if resources are scarce (which in modern economics is rare) it is only a pervading selfish and self-protective attitude that imposes competition rather than collaboration and generosity. Polanyi, it seems, recognises something of that in his emphasis on the embeddedness of economics. Thomas saw markets as restricted to a single type of commodity: this differentiates sub-types of market, and may be understood as per aspects in which the commodity is meaningful in ways that differ from other commodities.

    So, how is each aspect essential for markets to be markets (i.e. the structure of individuality of markets)? Here is a suggestion (which needs discussion). First, essential aspects for a market to be a market:

    Not quite so essential to being a market but nevertheless important to its well-running and contributing to Multi-aspectual Overall Good, and some may be essential for the long-term survival of the market:

    To Thomas, anything can be a commodity, and this is unproblematic. But to Polanyi, land, money and labour are "fictitious commodities", and it is dangerous to treat them as market commodities, because when one does so, one treats them in a way that is against their nature and way of operating, and robs them of their 'rights', especially workers. Our perspective offers perhaps an enrichment of Polanyi's view. Land, labour and money are defined by aspects that are important to them being what they are, and to treat them merely as market commodities without giving due respect to their other aspects is what Chapter 4 calls reductionism and idolatry and is Harmful in the way Chapter 7 lays out.

    There is more to be said about markets, of course, but the above shows how aspectual analysis leading to a profile of aspects can help us understand an abstract thing like markets more clearly.

    8-4. The Economy and Its Sectors

    What is the economy? How may we understand it?

    What about separating supply-side and demand-side? The economy:

    8-4.2 Sectors of the Economy

    # retail sector

    Economic sector:

    Table t8-sectors. Some sectors of the economy by aspect

    Some sectors of the economy by aspect 912,1350

    8-5. Levels in Economics

    Summary: Microeconomics, macroeconomics, global economics, etc. are levels that need integrating into a single framework. Dooyeweerd can offer such a framework: each level is a functioning in different main aspects, which also defines its main responsibility for bringing Overall Good.

    This section was written before the above and may need to be rewritten to suit it.

    Economics discourse refers to individuals, households, firms, governments and global situations: micro, meso, macro, global economics. Traditionally they are taught separately, since different theories seem to apply at each level. This causes problems, as many are now recognising. Dooyeweerd's idea of aspects offers a basis for composing an integrated view of them all.

    8-5.1 The Problem

    Summary: Traditionally, economics is divided into micro and macro levels, but other levels exist, and many want to understand how levels all relate to each other.

    The traditional division of the teaching of economics into micro versus macro is breaking down. The SNA 2025 exercise also finds that global economics cannot be treated as macroeconomics of nations. Though it may be convenient to teach them separately in university courses, in real life micro, macro and global interact and interweave and cannot be separated.

    Many economists now recognise that the sharp division between the economics of households and nations, discussed by Keynes, Fisher and others, is becoming untenable. For example, the ECB has an expert group looking at how to link macro to micro [ECB 2020]. In their redesign of national accounts, the United Nations Statistics Department (SNA 2025) also recognises the need to integrate household economics with macroeconomics (e.g. "The importance of recognizing inter-household flows and stocks: These may be consolidated in the accounts as they may be less relevant from a macro-economic perspective, but they are of crucial importance in compiling distributional results" [WS2 SNA Guidance Note]).

    Moreover, global economics cannot be adequately understood as the macroeconomics of nations. SNA 2025, which works primarily at the macro level, has a major Task Group dedicated to Globalization and how it differs from macroeconomics. For example, how do multi-national enterprises (MNEs) fit into national (macroeconomic) accounts and how may the importance of global natural resources be properly understood? Mark Carney struggles with this in his Value(s) book.

    The nation state as we know it, and its macroeconomics, is not much more than a couple of centuries old, yet economic activity at all levels has long been with us, for more than 2000 years. Therfore we believe that it should be possible to find a way to understand them all together, in a way that does justice to individuals, households, organisations, nations and the whole Earth. To do so requires a conceptual framework that allows economic theory and practice to engage fully with what is meaningful at each level, without reduction, and with due respect for each.

    We have not found such a framework in conventional economics and, though recent thinkers recognise the need for integration, we cannot find an adequate framework among them. The SNA exercise seeks this by reducing to detailed quantitative economic constructs. Carney, in offering the high-level idea of ESG (environmental, social, governance) values, points to an aspectual approach. We give this a more comprehensive and philosophically sound foundation using Dooyeweerd's aspects.

    8-5.2 Main principle:

    Summary: At each level, different sets of aspects are important. Since they are from the same set of aspects, we can expect integration is possible without denaturing any level. And new levels might emerge.

    As suggested in Chappter 6, at each level of economics, different aspects are of primary importance alongside the economic and govern the way economic activity operates at that level. That all these aspects form one coherent set, and we can understand inter-aspect dependencies, means we can bring levels together, and motivates us to do so.

    If we examine what happens in economic activity at each level, we find that activity is multi-aspectual, but that different sets of aspects are specially important for that level:

    When such aspectual functions, laws, properties and issues are displayed together in relationship, some significant links between levels become evident, some of which might have been hidden in previous economic theory. One is between the individual and global, in juridical, ethical and pistic attitude and responsibility for the entire Earth. Another is the spatial aspect of household land and national territory. Another, which has been recognised, is the juridical link between organisations and nations in policy.

    We do not claim those are the final sets of aspects at each level; others might modify those lists. However, what it shows is two things, which gives hope of a conceptual framework within which we may embrace all levels.

    8-5.3 Operationalizing an Aspectual Understanding of Levels

    Summary: The above theoretical view can be operationalized.

    That Dooyeweerd's suite of aspects covers both individual, social and societal meaning and functioning (also alongside mathematical and natural functioning) together, all linked by inter-aspect relationships, makes it likely to offer a superb integrative foundation to bring micro, meso, macro and global economics together.

    To develop and operationalize this in economic theory and practice has yet to be worked out in detail; research, experience (including mistakes) and discussion are needed, but the following notes might point the way.

    Avoid reductionism. Do not try to reduce the operation of the various aspects to the common thread of the economic, but understand - give respect to - the full meaningfulness and laws of each aspect.

    Recognise aspectual similarities. One is to recognise that functioning in an aspect is similar, whatever level it is at. Both households and nations usually operate spatially in the same way. Individuals, firms, national and global bodies function in the ethical and pistic aspects (with societal or globally-dominant attitude and mindset influencing individual agency and individual agency contributing to these [Note: Giddens' Structuration]).

    Avoid misleading analogies. Such as has happened in the Fallacy of Composition and treating government debt as like household debt. At each level, different aspectual laws operate and also provide the norms for operating at that level. Though in each aspect we may find analogical echoes of others, we must avoid applying the laws of the analogy aspect to it. It is no use expecting that laws that apply to one level can are appropriate to understanding, predicting or guiding operation at other levels.

    Do not think in terms of levels, primarily Instead, think in terms of functioning of each proxy-subject (household, community, city, nation, etc.), and also that of the human individuals who lead them and influence what they do, such as senior management in firms or members of parliament or lobbyists and media editors, especially articulate, charismatic individuals.

    We continue working on this, and readers might wish to help us. See our discussion of micro-macro in SNA 2025.

    8-5.4 Example of Multi-Level Analysis: The UK Dairy Industry

    Humans drink milk from cows, as it provides many nutrients. In the UK a dairy industry has grown up to supply milk, which includes special modes of delivery including the doorstep 'milkman' (male or female) and a nationwide systems of collection from farms (which used to involve milk trains but now road tankers). So the UK populace is used to consuming milk, and dairy products like cheese and butter.

    The dairy companies wanted to grow in turnover so they find new markets for their milk, and were pleased when they can sell milk in bulk to food manufacturers, which kept on finding new uses for milk, butter, cheese, etc. Ice cream was an early one, a non-essential that has become huge. The dairy companies wanted to secure supply so they enter into large contracts with farmers. They want to compete, want to grow larger than the next one with greater profits from the next one, so they squeeze the farmers contracting low prices. Dairy farmers cut corners in order to reduce the costs of production, sacrificing especially in animal welfare and environmental health. Meanwhile the UK populace consumes too much milk for their health.

    A backlash against dairy is growing. Should we completely turn away from dairy? If we allow some dairy, how much and what kind? The first thing to look at is how much of each dairy product is non-essential. Then look at the role of mindset and attitude, the pistic and ethical dysfunctions of "affluent, arrogant and unconcerned" or "selfishness, greed and apathy" that grew up, at all levels.

    At the level of individual and household we have expectations - many of surfeit of non-essentials. At the level of companies, we have presuppositions and aspirations that are arrogant or selfish, especially the dire functioning that is competition. Probably it would be right to shrink the dairy industry by 80%, more in the non-essential products like ice cream. Could not "A great day out for the kids" be had by other less damaging means?

    8-9 Chapter Conclusion

    # ===== tbw. # in Chapter 8, conclusion of chapter 8, say "This is not the final, or even complete. However, we believe it may well be more complete than most others." and what needs to be done.


    Created: 11 January 2023 from xnr2, then edited. Last updated: 12 January 2023 intro edited; more headings. 25 January 2023 Presupps of money as abstract; ontol, human. 27 January 2023 budget battles; money as vote. 28 January 2023 t-down pejorative. 30 January 2023 "stealing the wealth"; inflation.; holocaust; brought in NO's comments. 31 January 2023 intro to entities, meaningfulness, type laws, etc; dealt with NO's comments. 3 February 2023 asps of uniform currency; levels named; no sacrosanct; responsibility, ordinary people; agreed prices. 8 February 2023 ontological strain. 15 February 2023 rw. 2 March 2023 summary. 7 March 2023 principles. 11 March 2023 intro. 13 March 2023 new intro to money. 16 March 2023 theft; Bullionism; Fallacy of Composition. 24 March 2023 idolatry expands; ordinary ppl. 27 March 2023 rw intro. 31 March 2023 a bit. 5 April 2023 Moved Trickle-down to r7-ghu. 20 April 2023 dairy industry. 15 May 2023 money new way. 19 May 2023 bit from r5. 26 May 2023 money as vote. 5 June 2023 new ch smy. 8 June 2023 new approach, smy, intro. 10 June 2023 stuff from r6. 19 June 2023 inflation to r5. 19 June 2023 things from r6. 21 August 2023 gov taxes incr harm. 31 October 2023 funing r.t. levels. 13 November 2023 money box. 15 November 2023 f8-money, how we see it. 18 November 2023 slanting arrows. 23 November 2023 farm as bz. 8 December 2023 new intro, and re. levels. 30 January 2024 why level-diffce valid? 31 January 2024 austerity. 7 February 2024 govt-household unequal. 28 March 2024 investment. 2 April 2024 complete rearrangement. Decided that this chapter must be to do with entities, as originally envisaged, but treated in a different way: problems of Being-orientation, then Dooyeweerd, then resolving the problems. 4 April 2024 Levels, taken from xn.rethink. 8 April 2024 moved pieces around according to the new headings. List of aspectual profiles. 9 April 2024 completed moving stuff. 12 April 2024 editing. 13 April 2024 editing, incl enkapsis. 17 April 2024 rw 8-1 to 12 points, each with examples. 18 April 2024 8-1 intro. 19 April 2024 §8-3; rid old stuff; section summaries. 20 April 2024 Moved stuff to r5. 22 April 2024 stuff moved to r6, r3; removed ===; made contents. 10 May 2024 sacrosanct by asp. 14 May 2024 greed/envy, poverty, injustice. 16 May 2024 corrns. 25 July 2024 The Econ, Sectors. 21 September 2024 trying to get f8-being displayed: scr->src!!. 22 April 2025 sp., supp-dem; gov has corrective role. 6 May 2025 idolatry of firm. 25 July 2025 stuff brought from Hdox, but needs incorproating. 27 August 2025: Began major rewrite, bringing probs (E-O) and solns (M-O) together. 28 August 2025 practical effect of E-O. 29 August 2025 more. 30 August 2025 more (a); rw property para (b); finished probs of E-O (c). 4 September 2025 couple of small things. 5 September 2025 rid stuff moved to r3, and dealing with bits to add. 6 September 2025 more editing and harmonising with ch3. 8 September 2025 rid stuff to r3. 11 September 2025 note to explain money-creation. 15 September 2025 Began dealing with hdox stuff; moved some to Money. 16 September 2025 markets section begun. 17 September 2025 completed markets and Polanyi's fictitious commodities. 18 September 2025 removed money hdox to money; editing. 22 September 2025 started section on how to do meaning-oriented; example of thinking about money. 23 September 2025 completed 8-1.3 on meaning-oriented, and redistributed stuff; ren f3-sectors as t8-sectors; semi-mfd prods; a bit re money. 25 September 2025 rw pomo a bit. 29 September 2025 ?? 2 October 2025 money as goal. 17 February 2026 firms. 10 August 2026 bits. 17 October 2026 Box re Money. 11 November 2026 to thinkers/.